Every fall, I hear the same question from students: “Do essays really matter that much?” The short answer is yes, because essays are often the only part of the application that feels truly personal. Test scores and GPAs provide context, but the essay is where students can show who they are beyond the numbers.

One key point I’ve been talking about a lot this season is the difference between the prompt and the purpose of an essay. The prompt is the literal question on the page. The purpose is what the college is really hoping to learn about you through your answer. Strong essays speak to the purpose as much as the prompt.

Personal Statement vs. Supplements

The Personal Statement (Common App essay)
This is your chance to tell a story that reveals your character, values, or growth. It’s less about what happened and more about what it meant to you. The purpose here is to show depth, reflection, and resilience.

Supplemental Essays
These are more targeted. A “Why Us” essay isn’t just about why you like a college, it’s about how you’ll contribute to that community. A “Community” or “Identity” essay isn’t only about background, it’s about perspective and impact. Students who understand this difference avoid writing generic answers and instead show fit and intentionality.

Common Mistakes to Avoid
– Rewriting your activities list instead of telling a story
– Picking a topic that’s impressive on paper but flat on reflection
– Answering only the prompt but missing the purpose
– Writing what you think admissions “wants to hear” instead of your authentic perspective

Final Word
Essays are not about perfect writing—they’re about authentic storytelling with a purpose. When students understand both the prompt and the purpose, their applications stand out.

At Class 101 Waukesha-Brookfield, I work with students to brainstorm topics, refine their stories, and match their essays to what admissions officers are actually looking for. If your student is ready to tackle essays with clarity and confidence, let’s set up a free consultation.